« To A Greater World | Main | In Light of New Evidence »

One-Forty Four Over Ninety

Posted on Friday, February 22, 2008 at 03:09PM by Registered CommenterJon Gilson | Comments7 Comments

BloodPressure.jpg

My love for the medical establishment continues. I went to my annual physical last Wednesday, looking for a clean bill of health and a referral. Instead, I got orders to check my blood pressure five times a day and an uninformed dismissal of my referral request.

I have no doubt that my doctor is a well-intentioned man. He’d have to be, considering the way he dresses himself. Picture this: thirty-something, 5’11”, one hundred and fifty pounds, night-vision pale, dressed in a ratty blue oxford, a two-sizes-too-big checkered jacket, and olive slacks hemmed for an impending flood.

Clearly, this is a man more concerned with the practice of medicine than making the cover of GQ, a fact that I found reassuring—for approximately five minutes.

After the standard litany regarding smoking, safe sex, diet, and exercise, Doc strapped on the blood pressure cuff. 144/90. According to the device on my arm, I was a good four or five seconds from having a massive coronary, despite a resting heart rate of sixty beats per minute. This is an anomaly we revisit every time I throw down my $15 co-pay, and the standard prescription is to keep a log of blood pressure readings to inform future action.

Here’s the rub: I’m hypertensive by any medical standard. My blood pressure consistently tops 140/90, and the doctor’s playbook of pill popping will undoubtedly put me on some combination of ACE-inhibiting, beta-blocking, calcium-channel influencing diuretics that will kill me the next time I blast through a 21-round “Cindy”.

Granted, I can’t be sure Doc will put me on the ten-pill-a-day diet, but most of the other options are long gone. Changing my diet any further would have me killing squirrels in an attempt to get closer to my Paleolithic roots, more exercise would put me in the Guinness Book of World Records, and stress reduction would require me to take up chanting and yoga in my non-existent spare time.

Genetically, I’m a time bomb. My father’s heart explodes with a regularity that would make the tides jealous, and grandpa has had enough bypasses to receive an honorable mention in the Journal of the American Medical Association. Despite my lifestyle, I’m following in their tracks, one plodding step at a time.

Doc and I had covered this ground before without resolution, mostly due to his “medication first” style of healing. My blood pressure logs, transferred to his corpse-white hands, would invariably lead straight to the pharmacy. I only go to the pharmacy for toothpaste.

Fortunately, I had another solution. Here in Boston, we are blessed with an Active Release Techniques (ART) practitioner who also happens to be an M.D. That two-letter appellation means that my health insurance would pay for her stress- and blood pressure-reducing services, if only I could provide a referral from my physician.

I told Doc I’d like a referral, and quite reasonably, he asked me to explain ART.

“It’s a specialized massage technique used to correct soft tissue damage. Adhesions, pulls, tears, things like that. It restores muscle balance and range of motion through manipulation. My body takes a constant pounding in the gym, and this would help tremendously.”

I might as well have said I wanted to use heroin to treat my insomnia. His eyes narrowed, and he asked for the M.D.’s name and practice. He got it, but it was obvious I wasn’t getting my referral.

“You want physical therapy?” he asked. Shaking my head, I explained the idea one more time, getting into the details of fascia and trigger points. Asked if I had a particular pain, I unthinkingly slammed the door on my referral.

“I get tightness in my rotator cuffs, IT bands, TFL, and lower back.”

I hadn’t named a single disease, complained of pervasive pain, or given Doc a problem that fit anywhere within his neatly defined world. I hadn’t asked for pills, an MRI, or surgery. Stumped, he told me he’d need more information.

Ironically, he was exacerbating my hypertension.

My problem with the medical establishment is the same problem I have with nearly every entrenched authority—the marked inability to consider alternatives to conventional wisdom. Time after time, we find doctors with an unnatural affinity for the Physician’s Desk Reference and surgeons who believe every problem can be solved with a scalpel. The manual never mentions naturopathic remedies and soft tissue manipulation, so our doctors are left with a toolbox that’s missing a few screwdrivers. Even worse, the idea that there might be another screwdriver out there is met with more skepticism than the front page of the National Enquirer.

Next year, I’ll forgo the fifteen-dollar tour of the old guard, and make our friendly ART practitioner my primary care physician. When my blood pressure readings come in high, perhaps soft tissue work will be the first solution instead of the last.

Maybe then I’ll calm down.

Picture courtesy of admin.state.nh.us.

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (7)

Jon,
Good article about your experience. Needless to say, I wish I had the same to discuss at the current time. My past 3 years at a "Big Box" has not allowed me access to a $15 co-pay or any other form of group health insurance. So I've been managing my time looking both ways before "I cross the street" (in both figural and literal terms). Looking forward to the new horizons that our own box will provide, including being able to afford any sort of medical coverage. I definitely consider myself very lucky for not having any issues with my health since 2004.

February 22, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMark Reinke

Good article, Mark.

I had a similar experience when my triglycerides were off the charts. I read up quite a bit and then went on the Atkins diet. Came back to my doc 8 weeks later and my Tris were well within the normal range. The Doc said, "no other doctor would believe you achieved this without meds."

With CrossFit I'm on more of a Zone diet, but the mitigating factor (too many simple Carbs) remains a very small part of menu.

February 23, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterCraig Howard

Okay, yeah. I'm not a fan of doctors either but I know it's ultimately irrational. Doctors and scientists have saved people from cancer, cured all manner of ills, prolonged life and helped to improve those added years. That's cool. It doesn't excuse bad behavior, but let's be real and balanced, too.

CrossFit certification and following/designing/kicking ass in the workouts doesn't make you any more of a God than some doctors like to think they are themselves. It makes you fit. More fit than most. (Okay, a lot more). That's not to be trifled with but it's not everything. Like it or not, doctors spend years learning a highly specialized, extremely risky, insanely stressful craft. Often they are wrong. But on many occasions they are right or at least have a valid point.

Everybody's guilty of generalization and simplification...especially those with any sort of specialized knowledge. It's crazy for a surgeon to assume that the knife will save everything, but its crazy to follow ANY doctrine to its most dogmatic end.

The moment you're ready to take responsibility for who knows how many people's / patient's welfare and pay the malpractice insurance, fine. Otherwise, this is just angry complaining that won't produce an ounce of change. How original.

March 4, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterBrad Gutting

favorited this one, brother

March 26, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterErasmusgu

Well said Jon....It reminds me of a saying that we at CynergyCrossfit use often...."You can't pay some one to do your push-ups for you."-Jim Rohn

March 31, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterKeith Brown

Interesting post,

My dad is a cardiologist and I asked him about my own hypertension...140/90 consistently. I have a true RHR of 30, and I'm not kidding. What we may have is a condition known as 'essential hypertension' or rather that our heart beats so slowly that it has to pump very hard to get the job done and this hard pumping causes higher levels of pressure on the vascular walls.

My dad thinks that a I get older and my RHR climbs up naturally that my essential hypertension will go away, unless my slow heart rate (bradycardia) is related to a sinus node or other pace maker issue. Just some food for thought.

May 20, 2008 | Unregistered Commentersolly

Solly,

That's incredibly interesting. Less beats, more pressure. I'd thought of that possibility before dismissing it as too obvious to be correct. With your father's bona fides, it's back on the top of the list of probable explanations. Thanks for the input!

Best,

Jon

May 20, 2008 | Registered CommenterJon Gilson

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>